Paper faces complaint over bid to sway votersBy Lincoln Tan
5:30 AM Monday Mar 7, 2011
A Botany voter will be complaining to the Electoral Commission about a local Chinese newspaper after being given an issue published on election day asking voters to support New Citizen Party candidate Paul Young.
Under the Electoral Act, campaigning on election day - including distributing any statement likely to influence a voter on which candidate or party to vote for - is an offence.
The United Chinese Press, which is published in English and Chinese, ran articles and advertisements in its Saturday Chinese edition supporting Mr Young, including a headline that read: "Botany Chinese needs an MP who they can communicate with directly."
An article said a vote for Mr Young was "a vote to benefit the Chinese community" and the writer concluded by saying, "I will definitely support and vote for Paul Young".
The paper also carried a quarter-page advertisement for the New Citizen Party about where voters could get free transport to voting centres.
Mr Young provisionally finished third in the byelection with 1572 votes, or 10.5 per cent, behind winner Jami-Lee Ross (National) on 8150 and Labour's Michael Wood on 4154.
Both Mr Young's New Citizen Party and the United Chinese Press are linked to Jack Chen, the China-based businessman who was behind the failed bid to buy the Crafar farming empire.
The voter, who wanted to be known only as Mr Wang, said he was handed a copy of the paper by Mr Young's supporters outside the New World supermarket at the Botany Town Centre on Saturday as he went to vote.
The free paper had also been widely distributed to Asian supermarkets, food courts and shopping centres within the electorate.
"As a Chinese myself, I find it disgraceful that a Chinese newspaper has to use such underhand tactics to help a Chinese candidate."
Yesterday, Electoral Commission spokeswoman Anastasia Turnbull said the agency would not be able to comment until it had seen the newspaper.
However, the chief electoral officer had spoken to United Chinese Press chief editor Jerry Yang last month after having learned the paper was soliciting ads supporting Mr Young.
Mr Yang had assured the commission that he was aware of the rules and intended to comply with them, she said.
Mr Yang could not be contacted yesterday and did not respond to the emails from the Herald.
By Lincoln Tan
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/politics/news/article.cfm?c_id=280&objectid=10710631Editor insists election day endorsement legalBy Lincoln Tan
5:30 AM Tuesday Mar 8, 2011
The chief editor of a local Chinese newspaper has defended the publication of an election-day edition to support a Chinese party candidate in the Botany byelection.
Under electoral law, advertising and statements which could influence voters cannot be published or broadcast on election day.
United Chinese Press published an edition dated Saturday, March 5 - the date of the byelection - but its editor, Jerry Wen Yang, denies he has broken any rules because the paper was printed the day before.
The Electoral Commission said it considered newspapers published after 6pm on the day before the election day as being published on election day, but Mr Yang said he got his paper printed before the 6pm deadline.
"Our paper was printed on Friday and is only distributed on Saturday.
"According to my understanding, what we have published is not considered to be election advertising but freedom of speech."
A Botany voter is complaining to the Electoral Commission after being handed a copy of the newspaper on election day at Botany Town Centre by a supporter campaigning for New Citizen Party candidate Paul Young.
Both the party and the newspaper are supported by the Chinese businessman behind the failed bid for the Crafar farms.
The paper ran a headline saying Botany Chinese needed an MP they could communicate with directly, articles backing Mr Young and an advert for the New Citizen Party.
Mr Young finished provisionally third of 10 candidates, behind National Party winner Jami-Lee Ross and Labour's Michael Wood.
Electoral Commission spokeswoman Anastasia Turnbull said yesterday that the agency would not be able to comment until a translation had been considered.
By Lincoln Tan
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/politics/news/article.cfm?c_id=280&objectid=10710848